Gould for thought

In celebration of Film Forum’s upcoming screenings of The Long Goodbye, J. Hoberman writes incisively (and with lots of exclamation points!) about one of our all-time favorite thespians, Elliott Gould. We especially liked this meditation on the nature of Jewish humor:

Bensonhurst was a fertile field for cultivating Jewish neurosis—or, as Lenny Bruce biographer Albert Goldman once said, Bensonhurst was to stand-up comedy as the Mississippi Delta was to country blues. Goldman, a young professor of English at Brooklyn College in the ’50s, recalled hanging out with his wise-guy students and their pals: “They had developed an indigenous humor, wild and fantastic, collectively inspired but individually performed.” Their comic jam sessions, with each striving to top the others, were frenzied riffs on sex, family, and the neighborhood, delivered in a fantastic showbiz argot.

Analyzing their humor, Professor Goldman noted that while Jews imagined themselves “clever and knowing, scorning the goyim as dumb and slow-witted,” they also identified themselves with “weakness, suffering, and disaster,” attributing “health, physical strength, and normality to the gentiles.” The free-form spritz was a defensive narcissism run wild: “Instead of swallowing or disguising their emotions, these young Jews—consumed with self-hatred or shame—came out in the open and blasted the things that hurt them.”

Another interesting tidbit: apparently Gould turned down the Dustin Hoffman role in Straw Dogs! We think that if he’d taken the part, that could have been our favorite movie ever.


2 responses to “Gould for thought

  1. Straw Dogs!!, man, that would have been great. I could never watch ‘Deconstructing Harry’ simply because it was the role meant for Gould. And it’s just to painful to see with him, even though Woody Allen was terrific in it.

    Another perfect Gould role that never was ; Tevye in a theatre production of ‘Fiddler on the Roof’!!

  2. Sorry, just a little correction. It was painful to see ‘Deconstructing Harry WITHOUT Gould’

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s